“Replace tonemapper” not rendering

Hi all! This is my first time posting, but I’ve been having some issues with using the movie render queue with my post process material. I have it set to “replace tonemapper” and everything looks the way I want in editor and when I press play, but when I go to render everything looks washed out and low contrast. I’ve tried different image formats, and adding game mode to the render queue, but to no avail. I’ve attached images of what my render looks like (pink background) and what it looks like in editor/what I want it to look like (red background). If anyone has any idea what the issue could be it’d be greatly appreciated!