I beleive these are 2 independant bugs but they are highly related and we hit them at the same time (migrating 5.7 -> 5.8)
Bug 1: FBX assets originally imported in 5.7 lose their “Combine Static Meshes” import setting when reimported in 5.8. In 5.8 “Combine Static Meshes” was changed from a bool to 3-way enum, and the old bool choice from 5.7 is not moved into the 5.8 enum. The result for end users is that reimport fails in 5.8. I beleive the issue would also affect `bImportCollision_DEPRECATED`
Bug2: Legacy USD importer doesn’t remember import options after editor restart. Issue affects both 5.7 and 5.8. The user’s choice for “Kinds to Collapse” is stored as a editor preference rather than per asset import data (which doesn’t seem to be persistently stored into the asset)