Mutable Chaos Cloth breaks when culling mesh affects mesh sections with cloth

Hi folks,

We’ve been encountering an issue since we updated to UE5.8 where characters whose cloth mesh sections have vertices culled will cause mesh degradation in editor and crashes in packaged builds.

There are two issues:

1) When some verts are culled from the cloth mesh section, cloth explodes in editor. When this happens in package it can crash

01_TShirt_explosion: example of the result

02_TShirt_proxy: example of our cloth proxy mesh

03_TShirt_partially_culled: this is how much of the mesh remains after culling when the geometry explodes

Unhandled Exception: EXCEPTION_ACCESS_VIOLATION reading address 0x000001df50f0ee80

0x00007ffa7053202b VCRUNTIME140.dll!UnknownFunction []
0x00007ff78d9e5d02 ClutchClient.exe!UE::Mutable::Private::RemoveBufferUnusedElems() [D:\tc\clutch\Engine\Plugins\Mutable\Source\MutableRuntime\Private\MuR\OpMeshRemove.cpp:44]
0x00007ff78d9dfaef ClutchClient.exe!UE::Mutable::Private::MeshRemoveVerticesWithCullSet() [D:\tc\clutch\Engine\Plugins\Mutable\Source\MutableRuntime\Private\MuR\OpMeshRemove.cpp:739]
0x00007ff78d9dd78a ClutchClient.exe!UE::Mutable::Private::MeshRemoveMaskInline() [D:\tc\clutch\Engine\Plugins\Mutable\Source\MutableRuntime\Private\MuR\OpMeshRemove.cpp:866]
0x00007ff78d8c4a1e ClutchClient.exe!UE::Mutable::Private::CodeRunner::RunCode_Mesh() [D:\tc\clutch\Engine\Plugins\Mutable\Source\MutableRuntime\Private\MuR\CodeRunner.cpp:2432]
0x00007ff78d89e2c1 ClutchClient.exe!UE::Mutable::Private::CodeRunner::RunCode() [D:\tc\clutch\Engine\Plugins\Mutable\Source\MutableRuntime\Private\MuR\CodeRunner.cpp:8327]
0x00007ff78d917db4 ClutchClient.exe!UE::Mutable::Private::CodeRunner::Run() [D:\tc\clutch\Engine\Plugins\Mutable\Source\MutableRuntime\Private\MuR\CodeRunnerTasked.cpp:321]

2) If we cull the entire Tshirt so that the mesh underneath the jacket is removed, in editor the transient skeletal mesh shows no clothing data. But in packaged build we get a crash because the mesh section has zero vertices but there cloth data still exists

04_TShirt_fully_culled

Callstack:

Fatal error!

Unhandled Exception: EXCEPTION_INT_DIVIDE_BY_ZERO

0x00007ff73c7e9d01 ClutchClient.exe!FSkeletalMeshObjectGPUSkin::FVertexFactoryData::InitVertexFactories() [D:\p4\clutch\main\Engine\Source\Runtime\Engine\Private\SkeletalRenderGPUSkin.cpp:2579]

0x00007ff73c7c1a60 ClutchClient.exe!`FSkeletalMeshObjectGPUSkin::FSkeletalMeshObjectLOD::InitResources’::`2’::<lambda_1>::operator()() [D:\p4\clutch\main\Engine\Source\Runtime\Engine\Private\SkeletalRenderGPUSkin.cpp:2657]

0x00007ff73ce6e727 ClutchClient.exe!ExecuteCommand() [D:\p4\clutch\main\Engine\Source\Runtime\RenderCore\Private\RenderingThread.cpp:1533]

0x00007ff73ce46006 ClutchClient.exe!UE::RenderCommandPipe::FCommandList::ConsumeCommands<`FRenderCommandPipe::ExecuteCommands’::`2’::<lambda_1> >() [D:\p4\clutch\main\Engine\Source\Runtime\RenderCore\Public\RenderingThread.h:336]

0x00007ff73ce46048 ClutchClient.exe!UE::RenderCommandPipe::FCommandList::ConsumeCommands<`FRenderCommandPipe::ExecuteCommands’::`2’::<lambda_1> >() [D:\p4\clutch\main\Engine\Source\Runtime\RenderCore\Public\RenderingThread.h:328]

[Attachment Removed]

Steps to Reproduce

  • create skeletal mesh with chaos cloth
  • create CO with a Clip Mesh with Mesh node clipping part of the skeletal mesh with chaos cloth
    [Attachment Removed]

Hey there,

Thanks for raising these. I’ve logged an issue for them here: https://issues.unrealengine.com/issue/UE-399655

The dev team is looking into it now.

Dustin

[Attachment Removed]

Thanks for getting the dev team to look into that Dustin, is there any indication if this is something they will be able to fix? We’ve had to disable functionality in the meantime

Toby

[Attachment Removed]

Hey there,

We are trying to get it into the next hotfix; it’s not guaranteed, though, so you will want to watch the bug. In terms of feasibility, they are working on it and have not indicated that it is not feasible. Once it is fixed you may need to integrate the change.

Dustin

[Attachment Removed]