MRG - Holdout Rendering ignores deformers

Hi,

We use Movie Render Graph with multiple layer output and one of the layers is used to obtain a character matte. We collect character actors using a Collection and apply Holdout Modifier, so they render as a black hole.

However, we have noticed, that with the Holdout active on a layer, the geometry does not take deformers into account, such as squash and stretch. As a result, our character matte does not match the characters on the beauty layer and cannot be used in Post. This is serious, as we render a lot of cartoony animated movies and squash-stretch deformers are very common.

Please see the attached repro project. Made in UE 5.7, but issue has been encountered in 5.8 as well.

Please let me know if you need any more details.

Steps to Reproduce
Please download the project attached.

  1. Open /Game/Maps/HoldoutRenderRepro.HoldoutRenderRepro level
  2. Load /Game/Sequences/LS_HoldoutRepro.LS_HoldoutRepro Level Sequence
  3. Load /Game/MRQ/MRQ_HoldoutRepro.MRQ_HoldoutRepro Movie Render Queue
  4. Render Local
  5. Compare the beauty and Holdout layer outputs - a cube on the beauty layer gets squashed, the holdout layer does not take squash deformeration into account.

The repro project has been created in Unreal 5.7, but the issue exists in 5.8 too.

This is a bug. We have it JIRA’d up. I sent the Git link once its fixed. Thanks for reporting it!

Thanks Shaun. Sounds good - I appreciate it.

BTW. we also encountered another related issue - Holdout renders even if a mesh is hidden. For example, a mesh may have animated visibility. It’s hidden in frames 0-10, then gets visible in frames 11-100. The holdout should render only in frames 11-100, but renders in all frames.

Do you think I need to open another EPS Ticket or could this be combined with the above and get looked at together? Sounds like a simple thing to fix…