LocalMultiPlayer 2 Player Controllers 1 Mouse

I have a game that for simplicity sake we will say works like chess, turn based drag and drop pieces. From the beginning it was designed to be a networked multiplayer game and I have that part working just fine.

For testing purposes, and because I figure it might be nice for some people to have, I was pondering creating a local multiplayer option where 2 people can play at the same computer.

I really need 2 player controllers because of the logic that is built into the networked version (and honestly I don’t want to create a whole new logic structure for local play). I found the Create Local Player node and that seems to work, but after Player 1 goes I can’t get anything to happen. How can I assign the mouse to work for both Player 1 and Player 2?