Building static lights that suppress lighting

Sorry, then I’m out of ideas and I never used BSP brushes. I guess I would try to build a minimalistic example where the light building works and then see the differences between that and your current setup / continue from the minimalistic setup till you either end up with your current setup or encounter the problem/problems that lead to failure in your current setup.

Also here is a learning course about static lightning, and you can also access the project files Lighting Essential Concepts and Effects | Course