I am going to try highlight the levers in the image so that it gives a sense of what gameplay is like. Maybe I didn’t make the gameplay clear enough. However, with this new “highlight” of the levers it won’t look like it exactly does in the game so it might also be considered misleading.
The other thing I am going to change is to remove the island name from the thumbnail and just leave the word Escape, but on the otherhand perhaps Puzzle is a better word than Escape.
I am trying to figure out what is going wrong by looking at this link:
Here is what I am going to try as my new thumbnail.