Translucent water specular / shine not affected by shadows

What is the best way to make water? The problem I’m having, and it feels like I’m missing something simple, is the water specular / light reflection shine effect still shows even inside shadows. This is especially annoying when the player is indoors and you’re seeing the sun’s light reflecting on the water.

Take a look at this GIF … there has to be something small that I need to add to my material? A node? A setting? Anything?

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachmen…8968/Water.gif