Only one player controller is loading into the game

I’m having an issue where only one player controller is being created inside the game. I believe you need two player controllers when you are trying to controller more than one player with an Xbox controller. I have read that once you create another player controller is “should” use it automatically but that has not been the case for me, I have created two player controllers and only one of them is being used.

Any help would be much appreciated.

2555-player+contoller.png

][1]