Controller "Show Mouse Cursor" and Left Click Input Action Mapping

I have an Input Action mapping for Left click and have “Show Mouse Cursor” checked on the player controller. The left click input event only fires when I double click though. When I uncheck “Show Mouse Cursor” the input event fires normally.

I tried playing around with input modes and the only one that fires the input event with a single click is when I set it to “Game and UI”.

What is the correct way to do this? I am trying to shoot projectiles in the direction of the mouse cursor on screen.