[Preview 2] Unreal Engine 5.9 Preview

I’ve been defending the use of AI tools for at least couple of years now. Even in AI-hostile communities. I tried to bring reasonable arguments. Recently I even got a 2 week ban from an anti-AI activist moderator on BlenderArtists forum cause he didn’t like the fact I did not stop putting up reasonable for-AI arguments and the discussion dragged on.

One of my main arguments was that AI is just a tool. What produces slop is not the tool, but the user of that tool. We had slop before AI, we just have more slop with AI. Slop is a product of lack of effort and care.

So, as someone who is a fan of the AI technology, and hopes it gets better, and hopes to see more of it in the engine, is difficult for me to say this, but Unreal Canvas editor looks like a slop. At a first glance, it has signs of low effort and lack of care. It does not seem it went through any review of any UI design language person who is in charge of keeping the UI design and design language consistent. It seems it was just haphazardly thrown in last minute to compete with other engines.

I haven’t even used it yet but I can already predict it will be one of those editors that will drop the level editor FPS by more than half just by being open, even on another monitor. There’s so many random design languages and UI element styles mixed together. It just looks like a slop.

If Epic really wants to change people’s opinion on the AI tools, they should lead by example. These tools should be used to multiply the effort and care the Epic developers put into the engine features, not divide it. We should not fall down the rabbithole of quantity over quality.

These tools progress so rapidly that these days, the idea of completely custom game engine without all the unneeded bloat is now feasible for small teams, to some degree even for individuals. The only bottleneck becomes the amount of time, effort and care one has to spend in front of a prompt box for weeks to polish every small detail and make the design, performance and UX excellent, so the final result becomes pleasure to use. If Epic doesn’t do that, then the engine may become irrelevant within couple of years.

5 Likes