This problem was fixed in 4.11.
The issue I was having was with the button itself, when I hovered over it the button was supposed to turn into the Yellow box but it didnt keep the sharp pixelated edges I wanted. After I converted my project from 4.9 to 4.11 it worked perfectly.
I used the Border as the background color/image and the button has no brush for normal and the Simple box texture with a yellow tint as the hovered brush. Obviously it isnt perfect (its noticeably squished) but at least its a step in the right direction.