Can't See Joystick on Nexus 5

I’m making a game based off of the top-down project, but I can’t get the joystick to show up on my device! It works well in the mobile preview, but the device remains joystickless. Here’s what I’ve done so far:

  1. Made a new playercontroller to handle the new input
  2. In Project Settings changed the Default Touch Interface to LeftVirtualJoystickOnly and checked “Always Show Touch Interface”
  3. Removed the old axis mappings

Right now in game touching doesn’t move my character the default way the top-down project has it set up (good!), but the joystick also doesn’t show (bad).

Any suggestions on things I may have missed?