Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Unreal worse than Twinmotion?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Unreal worse than Twinmotion?

    Just testing yesterday importing a real estate building project with 0.5Mil polygons and 16k separate meshes (that need to remain individual), converted into fbx coming from BIM format.
    Trying to import using Unreal Studio result in 5 hours waiting the import to finish, and next a crash trying to drag the assets in the viewport.
    With Twinmotion this result in less than 1 min waiting, and the project immediately available in the viewport.
    Being Twinmotion based on UE I was wondering if it's just the Unreal importer that's bad, and will be updated with Twinmotion (superior) technology, or there is some tweak I was missing for make it work.

    #2
    I think Unreal Editor 's importer is very very old code.
    It should be remade. Also the Editor has a shiton of extra things loaded at same time so it is way heavier to run, more clunky, tons of more bugs, etc.
    | Savior | USQLite | FSM | Object Pool | Sound Occlusion | Property Transfer | Magic Nodes | MORE |

    Comment


      #3
      What tool were you using to export your BIM data? If Revit, there is a much simpler way using Datasmith and the Revit plug-in we support. If Archicad, you will soon be able to export C4D files and load them with our new C4D importer (4.23). You can also try exporting SketchUp files from Archicad and importing with our current SketchUp plugin.
      Sr. Product Manager
      Epic Games

      Comment


        #4
        My input data it's an ifc file (coming from Revit, but I didn't have access to the original Revit file). All the projects I will work on will be in ifc file format.
        From ifc converted in fbx using PiXYZ (testing it for this purpose since ifc file importer its not available right now in Datasmith).
        Strange is Unreal does have the same behavior when I converted the ifc file to obj using another tool.
        I was testing the very same file import in Twinmotion and Unigine and both of them didn't have any problem dealing with it, that's why I was wondering if UE importer does have problems

        Comment


          #5
          The UE4 FBX importer is designed to handle game workflows and it does it well. One of the reasons Datasmith exists is that we did not want to disrupt game pipelines by changing how the FBX importer works. Since FBX is not well supported in AEC/BIM (except for rare cases), we chose to focus on native workflows. Which is why we have IFC support showing up in 4.23 - which will be in previews in 6 weeks. You'll then get all the Datasmith love - automated lightmaps, UVs etc. Also, the importers for Twinmotion and UE4 are completely different code, so there isn't anything common between them at the code level.

          I know AEC FBX files that do load fine in UE4, so it is more likely something specific related to what is in your file. You can log a support request and submit your file if you want. Most likely IFC in 4.23 is the answer.
          Sr. Product Manager
          Epic Games

          Comment


            #6
            Will the assets contained within Twinmotion be release for use in the Engine? Kind of like a starter content for enterprise?
            Remi Bathalon
            Technical Artist, R&D
            PixiStudio

            Comment


              #7
              Yes we’re working on that... anything specific that you find especially interesting?
              Pierre-Felix Breton

              Sr Technical Product Designer AEC, Unreal Engine
              Epic Games - LinkedIn

              Comment


                #8
                Hello,

                Anything specific...

                I need a very simply tool (it's an existing tool in Tekla BimSight : "Add Clip Plane"). 1 clic = 1 clip plane.
                This tool adds a clip plane in the model view, just snaping a face to see the orientation of the clip plane, after you can to move the clip plane.
                In my work of BIM Coordinator, I often need to create and erase this clip planes to see clashs.
                This tool is existing in twinmotion (section cube) but in the form of cube and every face is configurable... too complex for me and mainly too time-consuming.
                Is it possible to create this tool with BP ?
                Thx
                Last edited by goodchild31; 06-03-2019, 08:56 AM.

                Comment


                  #9
                  HI there , yes it is possible.
                  Maybe you would be interested in taking a look at this post: https://answers.unrealengine.com/que...9899/view.html

                  Marie-Claude Jutras
                  Product Specialist LinkedIn
                  Unreal Studio
                  Report Issue Here
                  Studio Release Notes

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by pf_breton View Post
                    Yes we’re working on that... anything specific that you find especially interesting?
                    it could be unbelievably cool to able to export a scene from twinmotion to unreal, using twinmotion for fast prototyping and then programming and stuff in unreal.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by tahayaki View Post

                      it could be unbelievably cool to able to export a scene from twinmotion to unreal, using twinmotion for fast prototyping and then programming and stuff in unreal.
                      Just saw yesterday the last keynote of Graphisoft about AC23. It looks like things are moving in the right way for this point.
                      Any confirmation, PfBreton ?
                      Architect with Archicad

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by Glaag View Post

                        Just saw yesterday the last keynote of Graphisoft about AC23. It looks like things are moving in the right way for this point.
                        Any confirmation, PfBreton ?
                        I would love to create an environment for a short film I am making and export to unreal project. Is this development planned?

                        Comment


                          #13
                          The ability to load a TM model in Unreal is definitively something that is logical and we want to be able to do that. We can't make promises as to when this will be available as this represents significant technical challenges: Twinmotion is a "game" that is compiled and ingesting this data into the Unreal Editor is not something straight forward at this point.
                          Pierre-Felix Breton

                          Sr Technical Product Designer AEC, Unreal Engine
                          Epic Games - LinkedIn

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by pf_breton View Post
                            Yes we’re working on that... anything specific that you find especially interesting?
                            Some of the out of the box libraries of people, trees, vehicles etc would be great to have access to as a content pack. I assume that if its possible to move both ways between unreal and twinmotion in the future that this would make sense?
                            David Gillespie
                            Associate
                            Foster + Partners

                            Comment


                              #15
                              yes we’re looking at repacking the assets for unreal users
                              Pierre-Felix Breton

                              Sr Technical Product Designer AEC, Unreal Engine
                              Epic Games - LinkedIn

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X