Alan Noon is back in action to talk about his techniques for getting the best results from exporting and importing splines from 3DSMax into UE4. Alan has created a custom exporting pipeline with some script and is going to walk through how it works and how you can do it yourself. If you are a 3D modeler or a developer who uses splines, you will want to tune in for this enlightening stream.
Feel free to ask any questions on the topic in the thread below, and remember, while we try to give attention to all inquiries, it’s not always possible to answer everyone’s questions as they come up. This is especially true for off-topic requests, as it’s rather likely that we don’t have the appropriate person around to answer. Thanks!
But can it be done from Maya / Maya LT? Obviously if it’s using MAXScript, nope, but it would be nice to see more streams like this utilizing Maya LT/Modo Indie every once in awhile. It can be then be applied also to their big brothers (Maya/MODO).
While 3DS Max was (is?) the king for GameDev, especially in the AAA market, for some odd reason I would think if you were to “target” the indie market a bit more, it would have more of an impact. Especially, since once again, these techniques can then be applied to their big brothers.
I suppose a poll would be more in order to see what DCC the majority of devs are utilizing at the moment.
I think this is awesome, I was super thrilled to hear this is being explored especially since I use 3dsmax myself
I do think its problematic that a large portion of the community continually pushes for support of the software they might use, I understand that everyone has needs but you dont see me having a go at Maya tools (like the animation stuff) not supporting 3dsmax. Its because we have alternatives and can make alternatives of our own, unfortunately I feel like calling yourself indie is meant to come with some sense of entitlement from how people approach new features.
Im just glad that this is being pursued because I use splines alot, infact my preferred tool for splines isnt 3dsmax its Adobe Illustrator and I typically export from that to do extrusions in 3dsmax but I could also use Autocad. In terms of new modelling tools and ArchViz work splines are amazing, they can be used to do trims in housing quite quickly by copying the same lines used from the walls so its an extremely powerful technique on its own.
Obviously I want to see support for a wider variety of applications not just in the “indie” space (even though Im an indie who uses Adobe and Autodesk products) but that type of thing takes time and resources that a single programmer might not have, it also adds complexities not just in code but also legalities, format wars etc, I prefer to just have solid tools that work rather than flakey tools that support every application known to man
Hey all, I have attached the shape files, the macroscript, and the SplineWriter graph.
If you’ve watched the stream and saw the part where the circle comes in incorrectly, the issue was found in that the last node of the graph should be set to local, and the World to Local conversion on the out tangent was swapped. The file contains the corrected version.
I just got done watching and its great stuff I really like how this is something people can implement themselves, I hadnt even considered scripting in Illustrator honestly so this really shows how abit of different thinking can find a solution that works around the engines limitations. I do hope the conversation around splines and a proper specialized datatype continues at Epic, as AlanNoon said they are a very versatile tool which could open alot of doors