Brightness difference between static vs movable lights with identical settings

For some reason, when baking lighting, it will always be way dimmer than it should be, as seen in this image. The light on the left is movable, while the right is static.

This isn’t that big of a deal, but it makes designing lighting a pain because the preview is always brighter than the bake. Is there some brightness setting I accidentally changed somewhere that I can reset to have this be more accurate? I also do not wish to use dynamic lighting, as I am using static lighting specifically for better performance.